Almost a third of buyers blacklist bad suppliers

29 October 2012

Want the latest procurement and supply chain news delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for the Supply Management Daily

29 October 2012 | Adam Leach

Failure to deliver can result in suppliers entering a blacklist that excludes them from opportunities to win future business, SM can reveal.

In the latest SM100 poll, procurement professionals were asked: “Do you have a supplier blacklist?” In response, 28 per cent said they operate such a policy. Those blacklisted include suppliers that have failed on grounds such as contract delivery, financial stability or had been found guilty of illegal acts such as fraud.

Martin Wakelin, purchasing director – global elastomers at Trelleborg Sealing Solutions, told SM: “We don’t call it a blacklist, but all our managed suppliers are categorised as ‘preferred’, ‘approved’, ‘hold’ or ‘exit’. If we identify risk/poor performance with a given supplier we flag them as ‘hold’. If we see ongoing concerns they will be moved to ‘exit’.

“The ‘hold’ position is implemented on our ERP [enterprise resource planning] system to inflict the punishment of no future orders.”

The survey findings suggest, however, that blacklists are not common practice – 72 per cent said their company does not hold such a list.

Gary Moore, procurement performance manager of defence information, training and services at BAE, said that while he did not use a blacklist, there were other ways of weeding out undesirable suppliers.

He told SM: “Standard measures such as delivery performance and financial stability will mean undesirable suppliers self-select out of contention. The next step is to ensure such data is shared across whatever organisation you work in so you gain a consistent picture of a supplier.”

Brian Grew, vice president of commercial at Live Nation, said that while action should be taken against suppliers that fail to deliver, he does not use a blacklist. “While there are pragmatic and valid reasons to begin on a course to manage the supply base, a blacklist perhaps isn’t the best way,” he said.

Hounslow, Heathrow /Richmond upon Thames
Competitive salary depending on experience plus generous share award
Chichester with some flexibility to work in other parts of the County such as Horsham or Worthing
£48,423 - £51,284 per annum
West Sussex County Council
CIPS Knowledge
Find out more with CIPS Knowledge:
  • best practice insights
  • guidance
  • tools and templates