Updating prices, please wait...

Benchmarking

How do you make procurement great? Read all about benchmarking in procurement and how it will help your organisation

What is benchmarking in procurement?

Benchmarking provides evidence that Procurement is delivering value to the business in a rigorous, data driven manner – and reassures management that their practices are in-step with competitors.

The focus of benchmarking in procurement is to identify high performing organisations that excel in area of business, this could be in terms of capabilities, processes, or performance. Often, we can learn from best-in-class organisations, identify what they’re doing well and understand how you compare. You’re then able to set targets for your own organisation's improvement. You can also learn from their experience and avoid pitfalls that they have may have encountered during their development. You’re then able to set targets for your own organisation's improvement. Good benchmarking practices, helps with adding value to your organisation.

View model
remove

Managing time, managing money and mitigating risk are at the core of these benchmarking activities. There is an ongoing need to ensure that Procurement and Supply Chain activities are competitive and governed by best practice, particularly across these three key areas.

Click on each tooltip to view more information

> Mitigating risk > > > Managingmoney Managingtime

How can benchmarking identify opportunities for improvement? 

Good benchmarking practices are core to identifying and limiting supplier risk. As well as: 

  • identifying gaps in performance and areas for improvement 
  • identifying best practice in procurement 
  • gaining a perspective of how well you are performing compared to other companies 
  • helping to set performance expectations 
  • monitoring company performance and manage change 
  • ensuring the company maintains a competitive edge. 

What types of benchmarking are there?

The following types of benchmarking support improvement and help to add value to your organisation:

  • Internal benchmarking:
    Arises when one part of an organisation compares its performance with other parts of the same organisation. A good example would be where one company in a group of companies compares itself with other members of the group. The obvious disadvantage to this form of benchmarking is that best practise may sit outside of the group altogether.
  • Competitive benchmarking:
    Occurs when you compare processes with market leaders who operate in the same market as your own organisation.
  • Functional benchmarking:
    This happens when organisations compare functions, such as operations management, against that of a world class leader who doesn’t necessarily compete in the same market.
  • Generic process benchmarking:
    This is like functional benchmarking but compares individual processes rather than whole functions.
  • Customer benchmarking:
    compares the organisation's performance against the expectations of customers.

There is of course no reason why an organisation should not apply more than one of the above approaches simultaneously.

Internal vs external benchmarking
remove

Types of benchmarking

Benchmarking can be internal or external. Internal benchmarking involves comparing performance, processes or procedures within an organisation i.e. comparing how different departments carry out the same task.

External benchmarking involves comparing performance, processes, or procedures to those of an external organisation, such as a competitor.

Advantages of benchmarking in procurement

Benchmarking in procurement has a few advantages:

  • Identifies gaps in performance to focus efforts on areas for improvement
  • Identifies opportunities for creating more value
  • Ensures that you’re kept up to date with modern procurement and supply management practices in order to develop new approaches or challenge accepted wisdom and current practice
  • Inspires you to develop new approaches to challenge (i.e., accepted wisdom and current practice)
  • Validation of an existing strategy
  • Helps to ensure the organisation gains or maintains a competitive edge

Benchmarking can provide necessary external confirmation that might be needed to provide additional support for an organisation that has embarked upon a difficult period of change.

Disadvantages in benchmarking

Although benchmarking is a great method to monitor how your organisation is doing, there are some disadvantages to this method:

  • Data cannot always be trusted.  
    • Is the data from a neutral source? 
    • Were the data collection methods robust? 
  • Is the data comparable to your organisations? 
    • Is the sample of respondents large enough and relevant to your organisation? 
  • Data is always open to interpretation and scrutiny.   

Benchmarking data can be costly so doing some homework on the credibility and suitability of the information is essential.  Alternative methods can include attending events and conferences, reading case studies and joining specialist networking and knowledge exchange groups.  

Operations Management?

What is operations management?

Operations management is a key area within any organisation. It plays a key role in keeping supply chains operational in today’s challenging environment. Discover the key to success when thinking about operations management

Find out more about Operations Management

Become a CIPS member

Achieve your potential by becoming a member today. Whether you want to become a studying member or want to upgrade your membership to MCIPS, you’ll receive support and guidance whatever career level you’re at.

Sign up now

 

Benchmarking tools

CIPS Salary Guide

CIPS Salary Guide is an independent global survey with in-depth statistical analysis and expert insights to support you and your team.

Benchmarking tools

Skills Gap Analysis

Our Skills Assessment tools provide an in-depth look at your team's procurement and supply training needs and talents.

Benchmarking tools

Procurement Excellence Health Check

Transform your organisation's procurement and supply function. Take the first step with our free Procurement Health check.


Expand your value creation skills

"value-creation-skillstraining.jpg"

Procurement Skills Training

Accelerate your learning and keep your knowledge and expertise up to date with our Value Creation training courses.

Value Creation Training
 
expand_circle_right
  • What is benchmarking in procurement
  • How can benchmarking identify opportunities for improvement
  • What types of benchmarking are there
  • Advantages of benchmarking in procurement
  • Disadvantages in benchmarking
  • Expand your value creation skills