A cautious partnership

18 May 2012
Renata Towlson is senior buyer (best practice) at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS TrustI have recently awarded a high-value contract where the public sector establishment will have to find a way to develop a good relationship with a small private company to deliver the commissioned service successfully. It was not easy to arrive at the solution, however budgetary constraints dictated the outcome and the private company’s offers was commercially more competitive and the small panel evaluating the tender responses was united in its outcome. There were some issues with this deal, that, while particular to this case, have no doubt been observed by purchasers elsewhere. Firstly, the private company said while it did not agree with the way the public partner worked they were looking forward to working with them and would be happy to find a workable solution. This was a promising start. Secondly, the public sector organisation had a lot of misgivings about the commercial offer. They thought cheaper must mean poorer quality and were worried, without any evidence, that it was a high-risk approach and they would need to conduct in-depth due diligence to mitigate possible risks (despite the fact that this had been already conducted by the commissioner). Thirdly, the public partner was unhappy that all aspects of the contract were not under their jurisdiction. We agreed, however, to allow the experiment to go ahead and to review it on a quarterly basis. Supply Management readers know very well the difference between the private and public sector concepts of commerce. While I do not believe we will be able to reconcile the fundamental differences between them any time soon, I do think we could work together more efficiently to respond to an increasingly well-informed customer. It is not easy to build trust and a strong collaborative spirit between private and public organisations but procurement professionals now have a platform to facilitate a change in perceptions by designing a more economically advantageous business opportunity for private and public organisations to deliver a deal together. There have been many attempts at public and private sector partnerships and there will be many more still to come. I recognise there is a tension between these two approaches and I hope to use my role as a procurement professional to get the best out of them both.
Darmstadt-Dieburg, Hessen (DE)
Competitive salary and great benefits. Relocation assistance available.
City of London
GBP40000 - GBP60000 per annum + bonus + benefits
Bramwith Consulting
CIPS Knowledge
Find out more with CIPS Knowledge:
  • best practice insights
  • guidance
  • tools and templates